What techniques fall under the umbrella of “comprehensive chromatography”?
Pat Sandra: For me (by definition) comprehensive chromatography requires two-dimensional (chromatographic!) separation with on-line, full continuous development in both dimensions. Off-line fraction collection after the first dimension and analysis on a second column is, in my definition, not comprehensive, and neither are heart-cutting (for example, GC-GC) and multiple heart-cutting (for example, mLC-LC) methods.
All individual chromatographic modes combined on-line in two dimensions can be considered comprehensive. Combining phases is only possible with LC and SFC as they are both in the fluid state.
Lourdes Ramos: For years, the main (and almost exclusive) comprehensive chromatography techniques (CCTs) in use by researchers have been GC×GC and LC×LC, although the latter has been slower to develop. Several research groups have now started to explore the feasibility of alternative couplings, in particular SFC×SFC and CE×CE. Investigations are at an early stage but the promising results reported to date and the potential advantages for particular application fields (for example, SFC×SFC in oil and petrochemical research) will encourage further evaluation of these new CCTs.
Peter Tranchida: Good answers – I will only add that there have also been a few LC×GC experiments reported over the years. However, heart-cutting LC-GC appears to have a much more solid basis, and a wider past, present and (probably) future use. Apart from GC×GC and LC×LC, it is hard to make predictions on the future of other comprehensive 2D chromatography methodologies, as they are currently used in only a few research groups.
Enjoy our FREE content!
Log in or register to read this article in full and gain access to The Analytical Scientist’s entire content archive. It’s FREE and always will be!
If you don’t have an account you can:
REGISTER NOW – it’s FREE and always will be!
You will benefit from:
- Unlimited access to ALL articles including Application Notes
- News, interviews & opinions from leading industry experts
- Receive print (and PDF) copies of The Analytical Scientist magazine
Or Login as a Guest or via Social Media
This will allow you to read this article but you will only have limited access to The Analytical Scientist.Login as Guest Twitter LinkedIn Google+ Facebook