Conexiant
Login
  • The Analytical Scientist
  • The Cannabis Scientist
  • The Medicine Maker
  • The Ophthalmologist
  • The Pathologist
  • The Traditional Scientist
The Analytical Scientist
  • Explore

    Explore

    • Latest
    • News & Research
    • Trends & Challenges
    • Keynote Interviews
    • Opinion & Personal Narratives
    • Product Profiles
    • App Notes

    Featured Topics

    • Mass Spectrometry
    • Chromatography
    • Spectroscopy

    Issues

    • Latest Issue
    • Archive
  • Topics

    Techniques & Tools

    • Mass Spectrometry
    • Chromatography
    • Spectroscopy
    • Microscopy
    • Sensors
    • Data and AI

    • View All Topics

    Applications & Fields

    • Clinical
    • Environmental
    • Food, Beverage & Agriculture
    • Pharma and Biopharma
    • Omics
    • Forensics
  • People & Profiles

    People & Profiles

    • Power List
    • Voices in the Community
    • Sitting Down With
    • Authors & Contributors
  • Business & Education

    Business & Education

    • Innovation
    • Business & Entrepreneurship
    • Career Pathways
  • Events
    • Live Events
    • Webinars
  • Multimedia
    • Video
Subscribe
Subscribe

False

The Analytical Scientist / Issues / 2024 / Jan / The Greatest Analytical Odyssey: Part 2
Data and AI

The Greatest Analytical Odyssey: Part 2

This year’s Power Listers cite reproducibility and data analysis as two big challenges faced by analytical scientists

By Markella Loi 01/11/2024 3 min read

Share

The irreproducibility problem
 

Roy Goodacre: It’s well documented that there is a reproducibility crisis in science – some of these issues are highlighted in “A manifesto for reproducible science.” The authors in this paper conclude that a staggering “85 percent of biomedical research efforts are wasted, while 90 percent of respondents to a recent survey in Nature agreed that there is a ‘reproducibility crisis.’” This may be dated information, but nothing has really changed.

In chemical analysis, the truth of our measurements should be immutable. For the analytical science field, this is usually represented by mass, abundance, and identity. As analysts, we should be prepared to stand by our data and our reasonings should be evidence-based. In metabolomics, there are significant challenges in metabolite identification. My team's opinion piece on this topic was published earlier this year, which further pushes this ideology – ensuring metabolite identifications are based on common sense, facts, and evidence.

Jeremy Nicholson: Irreproducibility undermines scientific integrity by casting doubts on the accuracy and validity of research. It wastes resources as researchers invest time and funding into efforts that cannot be built upon or validated. This challenge has far-reaching implications for policy decisions, medical treatments, and technological advancements, as unreliable findings can lead to misguided actions. Publication bias arises when only positive results are published, skewing the scientific knowledge base and impeding progress. 

Moreover, the replication crisis in biomedical research raises concerns about the robustness of scientific findings. A lot of modern biomedical science is multidisciplinary and at the top end requires the integration of physical, mathematical, and biological sciences and this is also a challenge to referees and journal editors meaning that there is increased effort required to check if analyses are accurate or even appropriate.

As an associate editor of a major journal, I see manuscripts making impossible claims based on statistically underpowered studies using poorly executed experiments and without appropriate validation on a daily basis. These problems are found in the world’s top journals (and far more often than you might think). Of course, this is driven by the ever-increasing demand to publish and raise grant funding in the background of an increasingly impatient world. 

However, we as scientists are responsible for delivering appropriate, accurate and correct data and models to serve societal demands. If we fail to do that, we are invalidating the thing that sets science apart from all other subjects – the pursuit of fundamental and objectively demonstrable truths.

Jeremy Nicholson

Roy Goodacre

The data challenge 
 

Davy Guillarme: One of the biggest challenges facing analysts today is data processing. With today’s much more powerful, faster and more sensitive instruments, we are faced with a veritable tsunami of data that we need to be able to process quickly so that it does not become the bottleneck of analytical methods. The new generation of scientists is much better prepared for data analysis, whereas scientists who graduated in the 20th century sometimes feel overwhelmed in this area. Indeed, this science is evolving very rapidly, and this trend is likely to accelerate with the use of machine learning and artificial intelligence.

Hans-Gerd Janssen: We can perform stable separations with huge data sets, but they aren’t necessarily reliable. We cannot confirm if each number in a table is correct or if every peak assignment is on point. Improving the accuracy of this data is one of our main challenges.

Davy Guillarme

Hans-Gerd Janssen

Mario Thevis: In the light of the complexity of cause-and-effect questions, a major challenge appears to be the deducing of causalities from analytical data. Interdisciplinarity seems to be of even greater importance now than ever before.

Jessica Prenni: The mass spectrometry-based metabolomics field is facing a significant challenge in standardizing data acquisition and analysis – specifically in nontargeted workflows. This current lack of standardization limits the comparability of data across experiments and the reuse of data.

Credit: All headshots supplied by interviewees

Jessica Prenni:

Mario Thevis

Newsletters

Receive the latest analytical science news, personalities, education, and career development – weekly to your inbox.

Newsletter Signup Image

About the Author(s)

Markella Loi

Associate Editor, The Analytical Scientist

More Articles by Markella Loi

False

Advertisement

Recommended

False

Related Content

The Analytical Scientist Innovation Awards 2024: #5
Data and AI
The Analytical Scientist Innovation Awards 2024: #5

December 4, 2024

4 min read

Welcome to the 5th ranked Innovation, Pyxis – introduced here by Matterworks co-founder Jack Geremia

The Climate Conversation: Part Two – Michael Gonsior
Data and AI
The Climate Conversation: Part Two – Michael Gonsior

December 5, 2024

7 min read

In the second part of our interview, Michael Gonsior explores the pressing challenges in carbon cycle research, transformative tools and technologies, as well as analytical glimmers of hope

Green is Digital
Data and AI
Green is Digital

December 16, 2024

4 min read

Software tools can optimize resource management, streamline workflow processes, predict outcomes, and optimize experimental conditions – contributing to more sustainable laboratory operations

Could AI Ever Replace The Analytical Scientist?
Data and AI
Could AI Ever Replace The Analytical Scientist?

December 18, 2024

1 min read

Working closely with an ever-expanding network of experts helps keep our content relevant and engaging. And keeps artificial intelligence at bay, right?!

False

The Analytical Scientist
Subscribe

About

  • About Us
  • Work at Conexiant Europe
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy
  • Advertise With Us
  • Contact Us

Copyright © 2025 Texere Publishing Limited (trading as Conexiant), with registered number 08113419 whose registered office is at Booths No. 1, Booths Park, Chelford Road, Knutsford, England, WA16 8GS.