Subscribe to Newsletter
Techniques & Tools Technology, Liquid Chromatography

Computer-aided Chromatography

The chromatographic simulation of reversed-phase separations has become widely used for the optimization of gradient conditions. Such simulations use the linear solvent strength (LSS) model developed by Lloyd Snyder and John Dolan. However, elution modes such as hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) and supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC) are becoming more popular for the analysis of ionizable and/or polar compounds, and for the analysis of a wide range of analytes. Here, the conventional LSS-model can no longer be used to predict retention under various gradient conditions. In these elution modes, retention is a result of a combination of several mechanisms, including partitioning and adsorption, which results in non-linear retention relationships. Clearly, more elaborate retention models are needed to describe the curvature.

Clearly, more elaborate retention models are needed to describe the curvature.

I understand that this suggestion might seem frightening for the “hands-on” chromatographer, but I sincerely believe that existing modeling software, such as Drylab or Chromsword, dedicated to reversed-phase approach, could – and should – be extended to “new” and emerging elution modes, using non-linear retention models. I am aware that the parameter estimation using such non-linear models becomes more difficult, especially when performing a limited number of initial gradient scouting runs. And the parameter fitting becomes really problematic for the non-linear models for which no analytical expression for the retention factor in gradient elution exists. However, these non-linear models can provide a significant improvement in the accuracy of (gradient) retention time predictions, compared to the conventional LSS-model – and the extra effort would therefore pay off during the optimization of gradient conditions.

Several research groups have initiated isocratic modeling for these non-linear elution modes for a wide range of compounds.

Several research groups have initiated isocratic modeling for these non-linear elution modes for a wide range of compounds; for example, the groups of Pavel Jandera, Thomas Letzel and Xinmiao Liang are working on HILIC, and the groups of Caroline West and Eric Lesellier on SFC. Recently, I started investigating the possibilities of gradient retention modeling in these two elution modes, together with Davy Guillarme, using a mixed model (combining both an adsorption and a partitioning term, proposed by Liang) and an empirical (reversed-phase) model, proposed by Uwe Neue. The use of these non-linear models for the separation optimization in HILIC and SFC should in the near future be validated with real-life mixtures, including compounds with a wide range of chemical properties.

I am aware that, before computer-aided method development can be used routinely for the optimization of HILIC and SFC separations, an evaluation of the accuracy and the robustness is needed. However, it would be great to see the promising retention models proposed by several research groups being implemented by the vendors of the existing reversed-phase optimization software packages...

Clearly, we have to tackle the problems that might arise and answer the concerns of the chromatography community, but I believe there is a strong future for computer-aided method development that goes beyond traditional reversed-phase separations.

Furthermore, don’t we all want a greener future? The solvents saved by reducing the number of required experiments during the chromatographic method development has got to be a good thing.

Receive content, products, events as well as relevant industry updates from The Analytical Scientist and its sponsors.
Stay up to date with our other newsletters and sponsors information, tailored specifically to the fields you are interested in

When you click “Subscribe” we will email you a link, which you must click to verify the email address above and activate your subscription. If you do not receive this email, please contact us at [email protected].
If you wish to unsubscribe, you can update your preferences at any point.

About the Author
Eva Tyteca
Eva Tyteca

Completing her studies of Bio-Engineering Sciences, Eva Tyteca gained a deep knowledge in both (bio)chemistry and engineering. In 2011, she started a PhD in Analytical Chemistry under the supervision of Professor Gert Desmet. “I found myself to be the right person in the right place at the right time. During my PhD I implemented my math and programming skills to try to improve and facilitate the method development process in liquid chromatography,” says Eva. "Working together with Davy Guillarme from the University of Geneva helped me gathering knowledge about alternative elution modes such as HILIC and SFC, next to the conventional reversed-phase liquid chromatography.”

Register to The Analytical Scientist

Register to access our FREE online portfolio, request the magazine in print and manage your preferences.

You will benefit from:
  • Unlimited access to ALL articles
  • News, interviews & opinions from leading industry experts
  • Receive print (and PDF) copies of The Analytical Scientist magazine

Register